On the down low
or just low down?
by Mac Walton, aka, the daddy
or just low down?
by Mac Walton, aka, the daddy
"In these bloody days and frightful nights
When an urban warrior can find no face
more despicable than his own, no ammunition
more deadly than self-hate and no target more
deserving of his true aim than his brother,
we must wonder how we came so late and lonely to this place.
--Maya Angelou, “I Dare to Hope”
J. L. King, author of On the Down Low: A Journey into the Lives of “Straight” Black Men Who Sleep with Men(Broadway Books, New York, 2004), allows us to borrow his eyes and peer into the minds of Down Low (DL) men: Black men who sleep with other men at the same time they are sleeping with women. And here’s what we see:
* Men (some, not all) who often have unprotected sex with men and then engaged in unprotected sex with women, thinking it will be okay because their male lovers are “clean.”
* Men who keep their sexual activity with other men hidden no matter how much and how often they have to lie to their female partners
* Men that seek to distinguish themselves from gay or bisexual men. Gay men, says King, know what they want in another man and can talk about it like women.“Look, baby, I like a little spice in my life,” or “I am open. I don’t have any hang-ups with sex." But DL men want it all too, but they want other men in secrecy.
DL men, says King, are so secretive, “so undercover, so in denial, so ‘on the low,’ that they are the closet.”
* Men that are nothing if not deceptive. They “front” with women at the clubs while secretly making plans to “hook up” with men later in the evening. But they will not be associated with any activity that may call into question their secretive sexual activity. No gay parades for them.
* Men that, in fact, resist the concept of being gay like a crackhead resists advice. Though they sleep with men, they adamantly resist the notion of being gay and say they want nothing to do with gay people, stereotyping gays as men that dress up like Ru Paul, go to gay bars and march in gay parades. Mr. King himself refuses to consider that he may be gay or bisexual.
* Men that feel they would not have to be so secretive if they had more support from the Black church. While providing important information about the DL men and courageously confessing his own risky behavior, Mr. King fails to go farther and speak directly to DL men, imploring them to get tested, to immediately stop having unprotected sex with men or women and to get help. For example, he could have provided a listing of clinics in each state where men can go to get tested. He also failed to identify the implications of individual DL men’s risky sexual and deceptive behavior to the fragile Black communities. Since truth appears to be the first casualty of DL relationships, here are just a few truths for them and their potential partners to consider:
1. DL men stereotype gays, including gays in the Black community who act responsibly in the community and do not dress Ru Paul. king gives the impression that all DL men’s behavior, though dishonest, is somehow superior to gay people when, as King admits, gay and bisexual men are more honest than DL men. So who are DL men to criticize gay people?
2. DL men stereotype the Black church. Yes, the Black church could be more welcoming to the gay people. In fact, Blacks, as individuals, could be more welcoming. But this notion hardly justifies King placing the blame for his and other DL “lifestyle” at the doorstep of Black church. First, there is a thing called individual responsibility. Second, some Black churches, predominantly Black colleges (e.g., Morehouse), community centers, drug counseling agencies and others do provide services to gay people (despite cuts in such services by federal and state agencies). So stereotyping and blaming Black churches and other Black institutions to rationalize irresponsible individual behavior just doesn’t cut it.
3. DL men’s risky sexual behavior of having unprotected sex with men and infecting female partners is literally killing Black people (see data at the end of this article).
4.Though a serious concern in Black neighborhoods across the country, HIV and STD infections are especially problematic in the South. In a recent report, The Southern States AIDS and STD Directors Work Group concluded, “AIDS is out of out of control in the South...In essence we’re declaring a state of emergency…Unless some crucial steps are taken, the epidemic will get worse.”
Why does this epidemic persist? Besides the usual suspects of poverty, ignorance and needle injections, the CDC offers two other major reasons: Denial and Partners at Risk. About denial the CDC states: “…a significant number of African-American men who have sex with men identify themselves as heterosexual. As a result, they may not relate to prevention messages crafted for openly gay men.” As for partners at risk, CDC says it suspects that some women are reluctant to negotiate condom usage with men “out of fear that the man will leave them or withdraw financial support.”
The problem with DL men is, in part, about homophobia and denial. But, ultimately, it’s about a high level of risky behavior that is putting not only Black women but the entire Black community at risk. It’s not about a new lifestyle. It's about dangerous behavior, behavior that represents a full-scale disconnect from a Black heritage based on a collective ethic borne of an ongoing struggle to survive and even thrive against oppression. True, it is not the only risky behavior in our community. High rates of crime, drug usage, homicides, suicide, death from AIDS due to unprotected sex by both male and females—it’s all there. But the difference today is the exceedingly high levels of HIV and STD infections engendered by the unnecessarily risky and deadly behavior by some DL men.
Given this disastrous behavior, the daddy has a right to ask: "Brother, are you keeping it on the down low or just being plain low down— low down as in betraying the trust of your female partner? Betraying struggle of countless numbers of black fathers and mother who worked two and sometimes three jobs so you wouldn’t have to work as hard as they did? Betraying the love of untold mothers who made up white families’ beds (and occasionally got raped in them) and scrubbed hospital floors so you could go to college? Betraying the untold number of activists and regular black folk who preached, shouted, lectured, marched and went to jail so you could have the civil and human rights of which they could only dream?
The daddy just has to ask you, "Black man, how did you come so late and lonely to this place?”
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: "Black America is currently facing what is perhaps one of the greatest threats to our existence since slavery, AIDS. The public opinion that the HIV/AIDS crisis is stabilizing is wrong; it is getting worse for people of color. African-Americans make up 13% of the U. S. population, but comprise nearly 60% of those infected with HIV/AID. African-American women are infected with HIV 16 times more than White women and nearly 70% of the children infected with HIV/AIDS in this country are Black. The stigma HIV/AIDS carries in black America has only increased since researchers became aware of the prominent role played by bisexual black men in transmitting the virus."
--The African American Registry
21 comments:
I saw that King guy on Oprah. I bet he made good money off that one.
Very relevant, everyday. I just worry about causes and how they are often lost or diminished when relegated to a particular day or month.
Daddy, I think you're wrong on this. I think you a middle class guy that never went to prison or faced serious hard times. And black churches just think people who do this are gross. you too.
"Brother, are you keeping it on the down low or just being plain low down — low down as in betraying the trust of your female partner?"
Excellent post. The betrayal goes three ways, too: to the women and men they lay down with, and to themselves.
To Anonymous 7:19 - MacDaddy ain't wrong. Class, prison and churches ain't the point. The point is use mahfuckin' condoms so you won't won't be playing Russian roulette with your dick or using it as lethal weapon. You dig?
"Black man, how did you come so late and lonely to this place?"
Daddy, That is so Baldwinesque. I wish I knew what it meant.
I get the rest though and concur. No matter how bad it is or has been, we can act like decent human beings and have at least a modicum of respect for other human beings
Whew, there's so much I could say about this but it would take an entire page. I think my buddy, Kit, sums most of it up. I don't care what the cliche says...ignorance is rarely bliss.
Good post, MacDaddy.
Hey there!
I am a sexually free black woman who has taken the vow of celibacy as a clergywoman. (Yes, there ARE still clergywomen - and clergymen - who take The Vow who are not Catholics!!)
I should say that I use the term "sexually free" much differently than society does. My use of that term is not the same as the common use of that term!
I have known men who were having sex with other men...and TRUST ME...they are not that secretive.
Something profound changes in a man's constitution when he has been sexually active with another man.
These women who CLAIM to be "duped"...well...perhaps some have chosen to be blind. I'd like to go into the nitty gritty but this is a PG-13 blog!!
Any man who objects to being physically examined by a person he wants trust from has something to hide. Ladies just need to be blunt and tell a man, "look, I am not a medical doctor but if you want a sexual relationship, I need to get my flashlight and examine something."
I am serious!
This will surely weed out the down low brothas!!
Trust me on that.
I want to also mention that I don't think that black women are contracting AIDS at the outrageously high rates that they are because of unprotected sex with men on the down low.
I think that the black community as a whole has to be willing to look at the formation of sexual ethics and the reinforcement of illegitimacy and promiscuity that is rampant.
Now even as I typed that, I should say that I lived in an all-white former sundown town and went to all-white schools and NEVER saw the level of whorishness outside of those settings that I did INSIDE of those settings.
Whorishness occurs in all races and in all classes, let's not get that twisted!
Still...I think if we talk about AIDS, we really can't speak of it in terms of some disease that walks up and just JUMPS ON a person. No. It is a disease that MOST people have gotten because of their sexual behavior.
The majority of AIDS cases are not those persons who contracted it from unfaithful spouses and blood transfusions or rapes.
Thank you for this post, MacDaddy.
Anon1 said, "I saw that king guy on Oprah." Good. What did he say about living on the down-low, especially about the problem it caused with his wife or girlfriend?
Nicki: "I just worry about causes when they are relegated to a day or month." Me too, Nicki.
Anon2 said: "I think you a middle class guy that never went to prison or faced serious hard times." You know: You remind me of a gangbanger who told he had "to do some rollin'" to get some street cred among his buddies.Faulty thinking, bro. You don't have to twirl a gun around in a club like New York Giant wide receiver Plexico Burress to know that, if you're caught with it, it's a MANDATORY 3 and 1/2 years. You don't have to get AIDS to know about it. And, as for hard times, I could write a book about it. In fact, I did write a book about it. But that's for another day. But the point is this: I don't use the fact that I've had hard times to rationalize irresponsible behavior. How about you?
But you know what, anon? You probably have more to say. So hit me back on this blog, and you can have the last word. This is your blog, too. Blessings, my brother.
Kit: Isn't that the essence of this? You're betraying, living a lie with your partner? Okay, forget the amorphous "black community." You're living a lie with your partner. And when/if she finds out, how can she ever trust you again? If she knows already, is their any trust left?
Sagacious: You shouldn't have said that. You know how much I love Baldwin. Keep talking like that and I'm going to wind up with a big head. And I agree: Being on the down-low does not show one's partner even a modicum of respect.
CurvyGurl said, "Ignorance is rarely bliss." Well said. And it can get you killed.
Lisa said: "I think that the black community as a whole has to be willing to look at the formation of sexual ethics and the reinforcement of illegitimacy and promiscuity that is rampant." Yes!
December 2, 2008 8:29 AM
Delete
Daddy, It really was. I wasn't kidding. Startling when it hit me.
Were you going for that?
Sagacious: Since he is my favorite essayist, since I read him a lot, I'm sure it influences my writing. In this case, I think I was impressed with the quote by Maya Angelou and wanted to reference it at the end of the story. Thanks.
MacDaddy, I forgot to mention something...
My friend, who's a health educator, told me to always ask potential partners if they've EVER had sex with a man. Straight no chaser because there seems to be some ignorance around who can and how easy it is to acquire HIV.
Off the soapbox for now...:-).
@ Curvy Girl
I hear you on that...but....
How many heterosexually-appearing men who are trying to have the sexual interest of a woman would answer "yes" if a woman asked if he had ever had sex with a man?
Except for maybe P. Diddy or Dennis Rodman or Johnnie Gill or Chris Tucker, I can't imagine any brotha freely admitting that. Not early in the relationship when such a disclosure could be used against him later on.
Even Eddie Murphy didn't admit his (alleged) "stuff" to Tracey Edmonds. Men won't talk about it.
Remember the drama on Oprah between Terry McMillan and her Jamaican youngin' who confessed to her that he was gay AFTER the marriage?
I tell women at church ALL THE TIME...."if you do not choose to be celibate then demand the right to give an exam or leave that man ALONE!" They are floored that I say those things to them.
So many women do not understand that their life should not be gambled with.
Hey Lisa! Yep, I agree with you. People are so dishonest that it's unwise to leave your health (and possibly life) in the hands of another.
Please forgive me for this intrusion. I would like to take just a moment to acknowledge the life and love together of Dr Rajasekar Sham & Lucila Sham. I thank you for your indulgence.
U know i do HIV and infectious disease research. Mainly among inmates. The truth is that down low men is not accurate. Most gay men dont even have women inn their lives and mainly refere to men in the closet
Lisa, CuryGurl: I wouldn't mind a woman asking me that. It shows that she is careful about what she does. Good discussion.
"Herbert Chavkin, 87, a 55-year resident of Flower Hill and the couple's neighbor, said he respected Sham's decision. "Evidently they loved each other that much that neither wanted to continue without the other," he said.
Vigilante: Tragic but loving. I respect his decision. Thanks for sharing the story.
Torrance said: "The truth is that down low men is not accurate. Most gay men dont even have women inn their lives and mainly refer to men in the closet.'
Hey, bro. I actually agree with you that the term "down-low" is accurate. The report I read from the CDC agrees. They say these men are gay or bi-sexual. But as they mentioned, the men didn't view themselves as gay or bi-sexual. This is why they felt that ads to try to connect to this population failed.
On a more personal note, I hear you live in Atlanta. I was wondering if a soul food cafe called Gloria's is still operating. I'm coming to ATL soon and would like to go there. Blessings.
Good post McDaddy,
There is a lot of dishonest people out there, that is a fact.
Many people only care about what is in it for them right now, they aren't thinkin' bout you, or even about what is in store for them tomorrow. Many are even infected and have unprotected sex with others without their knowledge, it really is scarry if you think about it.
I was at a brothas place a few years ago, and this friend of his brought a young lady over and when in the other room and they did their thang, when they finished and the young lady left I heard another guy ask the one that just did his thing 'I hope you used a condom' and the brother shook his head 'no' with a BIG smile on his face. Then the other brother started laughing and said 'You done give her AIDS and shit' and then they both started laughing.
This was a beautiful young black woman, around 18 nor 19 years old, and this nigga is infected and goes and screws her without protection, then him and his 'bro' are laughing like crazy, they thought it was real cool.
I didn't, I left and never went back over to their crib again.
I was appalled, words can not describe how horriffied I was. There really wasn't much I could do, the girl was gone and these bros were crazy, so I wasn't gonna say anything to them, they'da capped me and threw me in the alley.
I'm just sayin', a brother and a sister just can't be to careful.
Somebody: I agree totally. And I think you exercised good judgment in the situation.
Such a sad state of affairs. So much of what went undercover for so long is now on the surface. Personally I think if you go around thinking you can just "do" any and everybody you're asking for trouble. They say "just say no to drugs". Sometimes people just need to say no to sex.
People need to stop and get a reality check. Not having sex isn't the end of the world but having sex with the wrong person could be. Common sense would say if the person doesn't want to use a condom, aren't they not using a condom with everyone else? Hello!!?
Post a Comment